Why You Should Not Trust Homeopathic Vaccines


homeopathy pills 600 x 300

This is a repost of an article that appeared on the Huffington Post Canada blog site on January 17 2013.

There is a slowly rising tide of uncertainty  in Canada over the necessity and safety of vaccines for childhood infectious disease. While the safety  and efficacy of vaccines is very well established, doubt continues to be sown among parents just wanting the best for their child, and the leaders from this movement often find themselves in the ranks of those promoting dubious alternative medical treatments.

Homeopaths are among the worst.

This problem was highlighted this week in the United Kingdom, where there are still charted and state-funded homeopathic hospitals  and where homeopathy has been a common option for some people, promoted by no other than HRH Prince Charles of Wales. The BBC programIn Touch investigated the sale of homeopathic alternatives to vaccines, called nosodes. These are manufactured using the diseased tissue, pus, or other discharge from an infected patient and diluted to such a degree that none of the original substance remains, save for some sort of vitalistic magical ghost that is supposed to wake the body up and have it fend off the disease itself. This is, of course, bunkum.

The British Advertising Standards Authority is an arms-length industry funded group akin to Advertising Standards Canada  that is tasked with enforcing voluntary guidelines set up by the advertising industry to protect the consumer from misleading and false advertising. The ASA has made several rulings  against complementary and alternative medicine manufacturers and practitioners over the past several years when they try to make claims that are scientifically unsupportable. A more recent ruling was against homeopathic preparation producers Ainsworths and Helios for products that were labelled as a homeopathic vaccine and being offered as a replacement for the normal vaccine schedule. Let us be clear, there is no good evidence that homeopathic vaccine alternatives work, and at the dilutions they are commonly offered, there would be no chance you could mount a traditional immune response to it: there is nothing in the remedy.

This has not stopped the promotion of these products in Canada however, and though we have tighter regulation regarding homeopathic product labelling (you cannot make a specific claim on the label without a stronger standard of evidence) it is clear that though it does not say vaccine, when a homeopath is offering you influenzinum 9C, they are offering you an alternative to the flu shot.

The efforts in North America have been led by US homeopath Kate Birch who, for a fee, will train any homeopath as a “homeoprophylaxis supervisor” to offer a complete replacement scheme for all of the childhood immunizations. There are several homeopaths in British Columbia and Ontario, including one who sits on the board of the new homeopathic licencing body in Ontario, who have taken Birch’s training and are offering homeoprophylaxis in Canada.

What is worse is that Health Canada, through the Natural Health Products Directorate has approved well over 60 of these products for sale in Canada, including DTP toxinum, which contains pertussinum, made from the “Sterile lysate of expectoration of untreated patients infected by Bordetella pertussis”. That’s right; it is made from the sputum from a patient, most likely a baby, infected with pertussis, or whooping cough. Outbreaks of whooping cough, an awful childhood disease that most often inflicts babies too young to be vaccinated, occurred in Alberta, BC, Ontario and New Brunswick last year with one baby killed by the disease in Alberta.

Besides a very flawed Cuban study concerning leptospirosis, there are few modern trials concerning homeopathic vaccines, and most of the evidence for their use pre-dates the 1960’s. These are nothing short of a complete fantasy and do nothing to protect our children against a host of deadly diseases, some of which we had nearly eradicated, prior to the resurgence of the modern anti-vaccination movement in the 1980’s.

We need to demand that our government stop speaking out of one side of it’s mouth about the importance of the modern, science-based immunization schedule, while the other side approves the sale of useless homeopathic hokum to be promoted as an effective alternative. If we do not, we risk a return of deadly childhood diseases like the 100-day cough of pertussis or the deadly, paralytic polio.

This is not a time to waffle, lest it risk the lives of our children over a silly sugar pill or magic water.

One Response to “Why You Should Not Trust Homeopathic Vaccines”


  1. [...] for most of the products.  Despite this, as I spoke about in my SN article about these dangerous products, Health Canada’s Natural Health Products Directorate approves around 82 of these products for [...]

  • Michael Kruse

    Michael is an advanced-care paramedic in York Region, just north of Toronto, Ontario. A semi-retired theatrical lighting designer as well, he re-trained in 2005 as an EMT-PS at the University of Iowa and as an ACP at Durham College, and is currently working towards a B.Sc at the University of Toronto. Michael is a founder and the chair of the board of directors of Bad Science Watch. He is also the recipient of the first annual Barry Beyerstein Award for Skepticism. Follow Michael on twitter @anxiousmedic. Michael's musings are his own and do not necessarily represent those of his employer or Bad Science Watch.